The Lease You Didn’t Read: Why Labor Leasing Licenses Could Sink (or Save) Your Global EOR Strategy
It begins innocently. A company lands a massive new client in Germany, Japan, or Brazil. They need local boots on the ground—yesterday. Payroll? Leave it to the Employer of Record (EOR). After all, the EOR is the legal employer, and everything’s covered, right?
Wrong. Behind the scenes lurks a legal minefield few executives or HR leaders fully grasp: labor leasing licenses. Miss this compliance cornerstone, and you could find your company facing regulatory backlash, court-imposed employment relationships, or worse—total market expulsion.
This article pulls back the curtain on labor leasing laws, exposes how EORs tiptoe the legal line, and gives you a global cheat sheet to stay compliant and competitive.
Labor Leasing 101: The Gray Zone Between Employer and Supplier
Let’s break it down: labor leasing (also called worker dispatch, temporary staffing, or agency labor) is the practice of hiring workers through one entity and having them perform services for another. In EOR terms, it’s the part where your “employee” shows up at your client’s office… but they’re not legally your employee.
Why governments care: Labor leasing was invented to create workforce flexibility, but quickly became a loophole to dodge taxes, skirt employment protections, and offload labor risks. Countries from Germany to South Korea reacted with tight regulation—and stiff penalties for non-compliance.
EOR vs. Labor Leasing: Not Always the Same
The classic EOR pitch goes something like this:
“We become the legal employer. You direct the work. We handle compliance.”
Sounds neat. But here’s the rub:
If the worker acts like your employee, answers to your manager, uses your systems, and works full-time for you… you may actually be leasing labor. And in many countries, that requires a license—even if an EOR is involved.
The Legal Litmus Test: Who Controls the Work?
Control is the magic word. If the client sets the work hours, tasks, tools, and evaluations, courts may rule the client is the real employer, EOR or not. That makes your slick compliance model a legal fiction.
Global Map: Where Labor Leasing Licenses Are Mandatory
Here’s what your global expansion team must know about labor leasing licensing requirements in key markets:
Country | Labor Leasing License Required | EOR Impact |
Germany | Yes (Arbeitnehmerüberlassung) | EOR must hold license or risk illegal leasing |
France | Yes (Intérim) | EORs may use “portage salarial” as workaround |
Japan | Yes (Haken) | Dispatch license needed; strict durations apply |
China | Yes (Labor Dispatch Law) | Dispatch via licensed partner only |
India | Yes (CLRA Act) | Requires state and central licensing |
Brazil | Yes | Outsourcing allowed post-2017, but with guardrails |
Mexico | Yes (Subcontracting Reform) | Only registered labor providers allowed |
UAE | Yes (MOHRE) | Free zone rules vary; licenses required |
USA | Varies by state | EOR vs. staffing blurred; co-employment risk high |
Canada | Varies by province | EOR must navigate staffing laws carefully |
Australia | Yes (State-level laws) | Must register as labor hire provider |
Need the full comparative table? See the appendix at the end.
Legal Fallout: When Labor Leasing Goes Off the Rails
Here’s what happens when EORs or clients get it wrong:
- Reclassification
Courts can declare that the “leased” worker is actually an employee of the client. That means the client owes back pay, benefits, taxes, and faces wrongful termination suits.
- Civil & Criminal Penalties
In Germany and Switzerland, unlicensed labor leasing can trigger criminal charges. In India or China, regulators may ban companies from hiring or blacklist them.
- Reputation Damage
Clients expect their EOR partners to be compliance experts. When they’re not, trust collapses—especially when a local government makes headlines out of violations.
Enter the Compliance Arms Race: Who’s Actually Doing It Right?
Leading EORs (Deel, Atlas, Rippling, Safeguard Global) have responded in three ways:
- Obtaining Labor Leasing Licenses
Some providers go all-in, applying for full licenses in countries like Germany and Japan. It’s a heavy lift—requiring background checks, financial audits, and recurring renewals.
- Partnering with Local Agencies
Others “white-label” local dispatch firms who hold the license. It’s faster but increases legal complexity and liability chain risks.
- Switching to Local Hiring Entities
Some avoid leasing entirely by opening wholly owned local subsidiaries and hiring directly, removing the licensing issue—but adding operational costs.
Checklist: Are You Crossing the Line Into Labor Leasing?
Ask yourself these 6 questions:
- Who sets the work hours and location?
- Who trains, evaluates, or disciplines the worker?
- Who owns the work tools and systems?
- Can the worker be moved to another assignment without client approval?
- Is the assignment open-ended or tied to a project?
- Is the EOR licensed to lease labor in this country?
If the client answers “yes” to more than half, you’re likely leasing labor, and you better hope your EOR is licensed to do so.
Toward a Standard: Will Global Certification Save the Day?
Unlike payroll or data security (where ISO and SOC2 reign), there is no standard labor leasing certification. That’s a problem.
But hope is on the horizon. Some forward-thinking EORs are working with Big Four auditors and labor law firms to develop:
- Jurisdictional leasing risk assessments
- Internal audit frameworks
- Lease license registries
- “Chain of compliance” declarations for clients
Think of it as the “FATCA of labor leasing”—a global standard clients can demand.
The Big Picture: EOR Is Still the Future—but Only With Guardrails
EORs are not dying—they’re evolving. Labor leasing licenses are not red tape—they’re legal oxygen. If EORs want to be the bridge to global talent, they must first stop standing on legal quicksand.
To the rebels building the future of work: know the law, get the license, and don’t lease what you can’t control.
Go To’s: What Should HR and Compliance Leaders Do Now?
- Map your jurisdictions: Know where leasing licenses are required and how your EOR handles them.
- Demand transparency: Ask your EOR for proof of licenses, local entity status, or subcontractor agreements.
- Limit client control: Minimize how much your client manages day-to-day work.
- Prepare for audits: Treat EOR compliance like financial auditing—because regulators already do.
IEC Rebel’s Digest— The IEC Group can help you audit your global employment setup by identifying labor leasing risks, verifying licensing requirements, and ensuring your EOR partners meet every compliance standard—before regulators come knocking.
Last but not Least: If you’re facing challenges and wondering how others are managing similar issues, why not join The Leadership Collective Community? It’s a peer group and webcast platform designed for leaders to exchange insights and experiences.
Introducing the IEC Knowledge Network Free Membership – Your Gateway to Seamless Access!
We are thrilled to present a new service that goes beyond the ordinary download experience. In addition to offering you the ability to download the things you love, we are delighted to introduce the IEC Knowledge Network Free Membership.
The Free Membership option grants you access to our library of articles and videos, without the need for tedious registrations for each piece of content.
The publication serves as a trusted resource to support executives in their pursuit of sustainable and successful global expansion. In addition the IEC Practitioners are available to discuss your specific challenge in more detail and to give you clear advise..
Take advantage of this valuable resource to accelerate your global expansion journey
